Short answer: A domestic quantum computing effort could give Irish researchers and companies more say over scheduling, experiment design, data handling and training, and it could build hardware engineering skills in the country. It would not remove the need for classical supercomputers, international research links or commercial cloud quantum services.
What domestic capacity could add
Most quantum computing today is reached through a few overseas cloud providers. That works for learning and for many experiments. Owning or co-owning capacity at home could add:
- Control of access. Decisions about queue time, priority and experiment design would be made locally.
- Data handling. Sensitive workloads, such as pharmaceutical or financial models, could be run under local rules.
- Skills. Building and operating hardware trains engineers in cryogenics, control electronics, calibration and error correction. Those skills are useful well beyond quantum.
- A test bed. Irish companies could try hybrid quantum-classical methods on problems they know well.
What it would not do
Quantum computers are not general replacements for classical ones. They are expected to help on specific problems. Classical supercomputers would still do most of the work. International collaboration would still matter, since progress in error correction and hardware happens across many labs. Commercial cloud services would still be the easiest way to start small.
The conditions that matter
An effort like this only makes sense if it is actually built and governed well. That means:
- Publishing quality measures, not only qubit counts.
- Benchmarking against classical methods on real workloads.
- Being open about what works and what does not.
- Starting with a small verifiable step before a large one.
Our position
This site proposes an independent ambition. Nothing described here has been built. The proposals are ideas for discussion, written by Mike English from Clonmel, Tipperary.
How we would judge it
A fair test of this idea is simple. Does it give Irish researchers more useful compute time than they can get today? Does it teach skills that stay in the country? Does it publish results that other groups can check? If the answer to those is no, the idea should change. We would rather say so than defend a plan that does not work.
Questions we are still working through
Who would run such a machine, and who would pay for time on it? How would access be shared between universities and companies? Which first problems would be worth trying: chemistry, optimisation, or testing hybrid workflows? None of these has an answer yet, and readers with experience are welcome to challenge the assumptions.
FAQ
Would a domestic quantum computer replace cloud quantum services?
No. Cloud services are the easiest way to start and would remain useful. Local capacity would add control and skills rather than replace them.
Would it replace classical supercomputers?
No. Quantum computers are expected to help on specific problems. Classical machines would still handle most computing.
Is this a government project?
No. This is an independent proposal and not a government programme or endorsement.
Has anything been built?
No. The ideas on this site are proposals.
What would be the first sensible step?
A small, verifiable milestone with published quality measures and a benchmark against a classical baseline.
All field notes